Pages

Tuesday, 21 April 2020

Batman: Shadow of the Bat, Volume 1 Review (Alan Grant, Norm Breyfogle)


Shadow of the Pants collects several Alan Grant Batman comics from way back in the day, and they allllll suck! Woohoo!

The longest story here is the four-part The Last Arkham where a killer with Zsasz’s MO is murdering Gotham citizens – except Zsasz is safely locked up in Arkham. Or is he…? You know how you’d find out for sure? Put a fucking camera on him at all times and see if he sneaks out via a hidden exit! But that’d be, y’know, sensible, so instead Batman has himself admitted as an Arkham inmate, in a cell far away from Zsasz’s, where he can’t see Zsasz sneak out. Batman supposedly has a genius IQ – but not when Alan Grant’s writing him! Four issues! That garbage storyline could’ve been wrapped up in four pages!

There’s a grim story about heroin abuse where a crappy vigilante called Black Spider kills a bunch of drug dealers; a racist beefcake fights Batman in The Ugly American; crappy Z-listers team up to try and win for a change in The Misfits (they predictably don’t); a Scots gentleman hosts a dinner for his enemies at his very own Scottish castle (of course Gotham has one) in The Thane of Gotham (the phonetic Scotch accent is painful to read); and yet another disastrous character, this time going by The Human Flea, fights Kadaver, a poor man’s Joker.

It’s not just that the stories are boring – though they all are – it’s that they’re plotted so stupidly. I already mentioned the flaw in the Last Arkham storyline. But also, putting Batman against the likes of Joker, Ivy, Penguin and Scarecrow in a closed-room – who thinks fatass Penguin and noodle-armed Scarecrow stand a chance of beating Batman in a straight fist fight?? Calendar Man literally throwing number cards at Batman in a fight though did make me smile for its utter idiocy. The art is just bad early ‘90s crap – rushed looking lines, awful, basic colours, terrible character designs, and the Batmobile looks like a Tonka toy reject.

Batman: Shadow of the Bat, Volume 1 is a collection of some of the worst Batman comics you’ll ever read – don’t bother.

No comments:

Post a Comment